“This will be our reply to violence: to make music more intensely, more beautifully, more devotedly than ever before.”
-Leonard Bernstein, 1963
So many on social media have posted this well-known 58-year-old comment as their response to the Ukraine war and, until this morning, I was completely baffled. Much as I love music, Bernstein’s directive seemed to be out of place – a tone-deaf denial of a horrible reality. In a parallel, is the best response to raging and destructive wildfires to perform plays with even more passion, or to dance ballet with more intensity? No – the response to the fires is to actively seek to extinguish them. And the response to Putin must, by necessity, be military in nature.
Even if you infer the moral lesson embodied in the quote is to avoid responding to violence with more violence, that approach simply means that the Hitlers and the Putins always win.
This morning I decided to research the quote. I was surprised to learn that it was never expressed by Bernstein in relation to war or mass casualty, but in response to a single event – the assassination of John Fitzgerald Kennedy.
Here’s the entire quote:
“We musicians, like everyone else, are numb with sorrow at this murder, and with rage at the senselessness of the crime. But this sorrow and rage will not inflame us to seek retribution; rather they will inflame our art. Our music will never again be quite the same. This will be our reply to violence: to make music more intensely, more beautifully, more devotedly than ever before. And with each note we will honor the spirit of John Kennedy, commemorate his courage, and reaffirm his faith in the Triumph of the Mind.”
Presented in context, it makes sense. The assassination of Kennedy was a singularly horrible event, not an ongoing tragedy that demanded a physical reaction. The assassination occurred in an otherwise intact and orderly society, and was dealt with quickly by law enforcement using procedures established for such occurrences.
In the above situation, the message rings with validity: Don’t lose your spirit. Don’t lose your art. Focus on beauty, as this murder does not define us.
It’s ALL about context.
-DPS